Page 1 of 2

My Version of Sleep Walk (maybe not so great?)

PostPosted: Mon May 12, 2014 2:00 pm
by U_twelve


Constructive comments welcome :lol:

Re: My Version of Sleep Walk (maybe not so great?)

PostPosted: Tue May 13, 2014 8:27 pm
by Will C
Pete, this is nice. Basil would be proud of you! And am I hearing some of that "fat 5&8" voicing from DH's day out already? If I'm being nitpicking it might need a tad of blocking late in the piece, but maybe that's an interpretation thing. Great stuff.

Re: My Version of Sleep Walk (maybe not so great?)

PostPosted: Tue May 13, 2014 9:46 pm
by Basil Henriques
I commend you for use of the correct title and melody, very nice.
'Constructive' are the type of comments you elicited, so: No problems with pitching, (intonation), phrasing is individually yours as are the embellishments, nicely stated AFTER the melody was established.
At 0:20 and 0:26 you let the notes on the word 'walk' (6m) carry on to the next chord (4m) and you should cut them shorter as the melody is a 5 and the chord is a 4m.


One thing I think could be improved is the weight you give some notes, you just slide to them without picking the second and third note, whilst this is OK for two, three is pushing it a bit. I'll explain: You are taking the required weight of the specific words that you slide to, and that may or may not be OK for a two note phrase but is invariably incorrect for three consecutive notes. The reason is the stressed words are de-emphasised the way you did it. Specific notes relate to specific words and you wouldn't speak a sentence with the stress on just any word would you. The relevant words within the song require the weight they carry within the spoken/sung line to be carried over to the played line IMHO.
At 0:52 and again at 1:00 you play the notes on 'i' with little or no weight or importance whereas they are pivotal first person references, and Santo Farina gives them the correct weight.
Don't take my word for it Sing the lyrics with your middle section and you'll see what I mean..

BUT all that is really nitpicking and nothing I say can take away from you endeavour which is most commendable, and after all, all I'm giving is my own opinion of what could be improved upon, from an already excellent performance.

As well as Santo's playing, this vocal version should help you..

Re: My Version of Sleep Walk (maybe not so great?)

PostPosted: Wed May 14, 2014 5:41 am
by Donny Johnston
Great job Pete nicely played. Donny.

Re: My Version of Sleep Walk (maybe not so great?)

PostPosted: Mon May 19, 2014 2:12 pm
by U_twelve
Many thanks guys for your kind words.

Will; yes my blocking´s a bit sloppy & that´s on a good day :lol: . Hopefully it can only get better... Recorded before Davids do :)

Basil; thanks for your very detailed analysis. I have given it much thought as well as listening to the original record, something which I must confess I haven´t done since it was released, & the vocal version as posted. My conclusion is that you are completely correct (but then you already knew that :lol:) & I will seek to modify my approach to this iconic piece.

Cheers Donny, hope your feeling better.

Back to the practice room to prepare for SESGF. Yes I know, hard to beleive, that as badley as I play, I actually do practice :guitar:

Re: My Version of Sleep Walk (maybe not so great?)

PostPosted: Sun Jun 01, 2014 7:58 am
by mick hearn
Enjoyed that.. mind you I shall be taking on board Basils comments as well. I think there should be a separate subject on playing tips and Basils would be one of those put at the top. Now I want to go back and do my stuff again.

Back to your version though, I thought it was nice and clear, not overdone and very precise. Loved it.

Re: My Version of Sleep Walk (maybe not so great?)

PostPosted: Sun Jun 01, 2014 9:17 pm
by Shaun
Well Played Pete, enjoyed That

Re: My Version of Sleep Walk (maybe not so great?)

PostPosted: Tue Jun 03, 2014 6:51 am
by David Hartley
So?

Where the link to the video or audio?

Re: My Version of Sleep Walk (maybe not so great?)

PostPosted: Tue Jun 03, 2014 9:19 am
by Ken Byng
It's at the top of the page where it always has been.

Re: My Version of Sleep Walk (maybe not so great?)

PostPosted: Wed Jun 04, 2014 1:43 pm
by David Hartley
I can't see a link, or nothing?

Wierd...

Perhaps someone could reply posting the YT link?

I can see links on other threads....