Page 1 of 2

Great version of Sleepwalk.

PostPosted: Mon May 05, 2014 1:43 pm
by Uncle Roy
Just love everything Bishop Ronnie Hall puts out on video.
Here is his rendition of the classic sleepwalk in his sacred steel style. Great track.


Re: Great version of Sleepwalk.

PostPosted: Mon May 05, 2014 5:49 pm
by Basil Henriques
Good version yes, but disrespectful to Santo, Johnny and Ann Farina who wrote it.. It's Sleep Walk.. TWO words..
Also The bishop's version doesn't follow the melody or phrasing of the words as the composers wrote them ? why is that ?
Also the Harmonics on the intro and other sections of the original are an intrinsic and integral part of the written music and as such form part of the tune/melody..
Is it a case of "Broken Ears" or just not caring ?

Image

Image

Image

:twisted: :twisted: :twisted:

Re: Great version of Sleepwalk.

PostPosted: Tue May 06, 2014 8:11 am
by Ken Byng
I must agree with Basil. This version must have more choruses than Agadoo!!!

He sounds to me as though he is ad libbing all the way through, and the whole thing lacks good taste and finesse. He has the right vibrato to do this number, but has turned it into a blues thing at times. I think the Bishop needs to acquaint himself with the record for a number of reasons.

If you are going to play this all time classic, at least play it right. Sorry to disagree Roy.

Re: Great version of Sleepwalk.

PostPosted: Tue May 06, 2014 8:24 am
by Uncle Roy
I realise what you are both saying but I did say his rendition. Surely poetic licence is allowed even in music.
Am I right or wrong? :) If I'm wrong fair do.
I heard even the top musicians ad lib through classic songs before, is that wrong?

Re: Great version of Sleepwalk.

PostPosted: Tue May 06, 2014 8:33 am
by Ken Byng
It's interesting to hear this version, which is one of 2 black and white live TV performances by S&J on YouTube



with this this one by Johnny Farina who murders it with his appalling intonation and OTT body actions.



Santo Farina has more class in one note than his brother provides in the whole number.

Roy you are not wrong, it's all down to personal taste. Anyone can exhibit poetic license, and I have heard larry Carlton and Jeff Beck do just that with Sleep Walk. The Bishop's version doesn't cook it for me personally, but you obviously enjoy it. For me (and Basil), he leaves some of the key and integral parts of the number out completely.

Re: Great version of Sleepwalk.

PostPosted: Tue May 06, 2014 9:13 am
by SteelieAJK
I'm with Uncle Roy, I find Bishop Hall's Sacred Steel tinged interpretations fabulous. I can't get precious on how faithful a pop song is reproduced. A bit of soulful improvisation sounds great to me.

Re: Great version of Sleepwalk.

PostPosted: Tue May 06, 2014 10:40 am
by Basil Henriques
This is the ONLY steel guitar instrumental EVER to win a Grammy and as such is seminal and definitive. Far too many essential components are missing from this 'version' by Bishop Ronnie Hall. Away from the fact that he obviously doesn't care if he plays it correctly, it's an insult to the composers and also a surreptitious evading of royalties by using an incorrect name..A dishonest and shameful practise, especially as the correct title is known to be "Sleep Walk"
Two minutes or less searching on the internet would have given him the correct title, so it's an obvious deliberate evasion.
Evading the performing Rights/Royalties is theft..
Further, he misses out 8 bars of the melody before the middle section, careless to say the least, if he played the correct notes it wouldn't be so bad.

I listen at the same depth as Ken, but what's also obvious is that not everybody can get into the mindset of the player. I can and I know what I know, it's unfortunate that there's no way of imparting my ears and mind onto others.

Also I must endorse Ken's comments about Johnny Farina, capitalising on his brother's hit and pretending that HE is the sound of Sleep Walk !! A total second rate copy and most misleading in his publicity, enough so that here in the UK he would be in breach of the trades description act regarding him being the sound of Sleep Walk...

As far as improvisation and poetic licence, there is a standard way of applying that criteria, improvisation occurs AFTER the melody is established: That is in all good music circles. Why should the steel guitar world be the exception ?

Re: Great version of Sleepwalk.

PostPosted: Tue May 06, 2014 11:55 am
by Shaun
Intersting this, Incidently I haven't heard the versions yet (until i get home - cant use you-tube at work).
I've learned one thing Basil, never realised it was Sleep Walk, you are obviously correct but I have always ( incorrectly ) refered to this great Tune as Sleepwalk. I will of course from now on refer to it by its correct title.
Question : If any of us want to publish (i.e upload to You-Tube) a version of any song, I understand we're are in Breach of Copywrite, What is the correct procedure to get over this ? (Bearing in mind we're not making any money just sharing our attempts with freinds).

Re: Great version of Sleepwalk.

PostPosted: Tue May 06, 2014 12:21 pm
by Basil Henriques
Shaun wrote:Question : If any of us want to publish (i.e upload to You-Tube) a version of any song, I understand we're are in Breach of Copywrite, What is the correct procedure to get over this ? (Bearing in mind we're not making any money just sharing our attempts with friends).

Well if you have the track already on an album that you've commercially released, and paid for the MCPS etc, then you are OK. Other than that ANY tune upload to the web for public consumption/viewing/listening is subject to copyright law. When you sign up to YouTube you sign a 'waiver' accepting responsibility for the copyright of your posting and exonerating them from all responsibilities..
Making money does not come into the equation, it's whether it's public or not.
This may be heavy reading but is essential if you don't want a knock on your door someday..
The main page to work from is this:-
https://support.google.com/youtube/topi ... ic=2676339



Fair use myths

There is some misinformation out there that might lead you to believe fair use automatically applies if you say a few magic words. There is actually no silver bullet that will guarantee you are protected by fair use when you use copyrighted material you don’t own. Courts will consider all four of the factors described above and weigh them on a case-by-case basis. Here are some common myths:
Myth #1: If I give credit to the copyright owner, my use is automatically fair use.

As you saw above, transformativeness is usually a key in the fair use analysis. Giving credit to the owner of a copyrighted work won’t by itself turn a non-transformative copy of their material into fair use. Phrases such as “all rights go to the author” and “I do not own” do not automatically mean you are making fair use of that material – nor do they mean you have the copyright owner’s permission.

Myth #2: If I post a disclaimer on my video, my use is fair use.

As we noted above, there are no magic words that will do this for you. Posting the four factors of fair use in your video or including the phrase “no infringement intended” won’t automatically protect you from a claim of copyright infringement.

Myth #3: “Entertainment” or “non-profit” uses are automatically fair use.

Courts will look carefully at the purpose of your use in evaluating whether it is fair, but the three remaining factors also need to be considered. Declaring your upload to be “for entertainment purposes only”, for example, is unlikely to tip the scales in the fair use balancing test. Similarly, “non-profit” uses are favoured in the fair use analysis, but it’s not an automatic defence by itself.

Myth #4: If I add any original material I created to someone else’s copyrighted work, my use is fair use.

Even if you’ve added a little something of your own to someone else’s content, you might not be able to take advantage of the fair use defence – particularly if your creation fails to add new expression, meaning or message to the original. As with all the other cases discussed here, courts will consider all four factors of the fair use test, including the quantity of the original used.
What is Copyright?

When a person creates an original work that is fixed in a physical medium, he or she automatically owns copyright to the work. Copyright ownership gives the owner the exclusive right to use the work in certain, specific ways. Many types of works are eligible for copyright protection.

Audiovisual works, such as TV shows, movies, and online videos

Sound recordings and musical compositions

Written works, such as lectures, articles, books, and musical compositions

Visual works, such as paintings, posters, and advertisements

Video games and computer software

Dramatic works, such as plays and musicals

Ideas, facts, and processes are not subject to copyright. In order to be eligible for copyright protection, a work must be both creative and fixed in a tangible medium. Names and titles are not, by themselves, subject to copyright.
Is it possible to use a copyright-protected work without infringing?

In some circumstances, it is possible to use a copyright-protected work without infringing the owner’s copyright. For more about this, you may want to learn about fair use.
What's eligible for a Creative Commons license

Please understand that you may only mark your uploaded video with a Creative Commons license if it consists entirely of content licensable by you under the CC BY license. Some examples of such licensable content are:

Your originally created content
Other videos marked with a CC BY license
Videos in the public domain

https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2797466?hl=en

Re: Great version of Sleepwalk.

PostPosted: Tue May 06, 2014 12:56 pm
by Shaun
Many Thanks for your comprehensive reply Basil.
I will have a good read.